The following open letter was reprinted from Losing
Fath in Faith (1992).
by Dan Barker
You asked me to consider Christianity as the answer for my life. I have done that. I
consider it untrue, repugnant, and harmful.
You expect me to believe Jesus was born of a virgin impregnated by a ghost? Do you believe
all the crazy tales of ancient religions? Julius Caesar was reportedly born of a virgin;
Roman historian Seutonius said Augustus bodily rose to heaven when he died; and Buddha was
supposedly born speaking. You don't believe all that, do you? Why do you expect me to
swallow the fables of Christianity?
I find it incredible that you ask me to believe that the earth was created in six literal
days; women come from a man's rib; a snake, a donkey, and a burning bush spoke human
language; the entire world was flooded, covering the mountains to drown evil; all animal
species, millions of them, rode on one boat; language variations stem from the tower of
Babel; Moses had a magic wand; the Nile turned to blood; a stick turned into a snake;
witches, wizards, and sorcerers really exist; food rained from the sky for 40 years; people
were cured by the sight of a brass serpent; the sun stood still to help Joshua win a battle,
and it went backward for King Hezekiah; men survived unaided in a fiery furnace; a
detached hand floated in the air and wrote on a wall; men followed a star which directed
them to a particular house; Jesus walked on water unaided; fish and bread magically
multiplied to feed the hungry; water instantly turned into wine; mental illness is caused by
demons; a “devil” with wings exists who causes evil; people were healed by stepping into a
pool agitated by angels; disembodied voiced spoke from the sky; Jesus vanished and later
materialized from thin air; people were healed by Peter's shadow; angels broke people out of
jail; a fiery lake of eternal torment awaits unbelievers under the earth ... while there is
life-after-death in a city which is 1,500 miles cubed, with mansions and food, for
If you believe these stories, then you are the one with the problem, not me. These myths
violate natural law, contradict science, and fail to correspond with reality or logic. If
you can't see that, then you can't separate truth from fantasy. It doesn't matter how many
people accept delusions inflicted by “holy” men; a widely held lie is still a lie. If you
are so gullible, then you are like the child who believes the older brother who says there
is a monster in the hallway. But there is nothing to be afraid of; go turn on the light and
look for yourself.
If Christianity were simply untrue I would not be too concerned. Santa is untrue, but it is
a harmless myth which people outgrow. But Christianity, besides being false, is also
abhorrent. It amazes me that you claim to love the god of the bible, a hateful, arrogant,
sexist, cruel being who can't tolerate criticism. I would not want to live in the same
neighborhood with such a creature!
The biblical god is a macho male warrior. Though he said Thou shalt not kill,
he ordered death for all opposition, wholesale drowning and mass exterminations; punishes
offspring to the fourth generation (Ex. 20:5); ordered pregnant women and children to be
ripped up (Hos. 13:16); demands animal and human blood to appease his angry vanity; is
partial to one race of people; judges women to be inferior to men; is a sadist who
created a hell to torture unbelievers; created evil (Is. 45:7); discriminated against the
handicapped (Lev. 21:18-23); ordered virgins to be kept as spoils of war (Num. 31:15-18,
Deut. 21:11-14); spread dung on people's faces (Mal. 2:3); sent bears to devour 42 children
who teased a prophet (II Kings 2:23-24); punishes people with snakes, dogs, dragons,
drunkenness, swords, arrows, axes, fire, famine, and infanticide; and said fathers should
eat their sons (Ez. 5:10). Is that nice? Would you want to live next door to such a
And Jesus is a chip off the old block. He said, “I and my father are one,” and he upheld
“every jot and tittle” of the Old Testament law. Mt. 5:18 He preached the same old
judgment: vengeance and death, wrath and distress, hell and torture for all nonconformists.
He believed in demons, angels and spirits. He never denounced the subjugation of slaves or
women. Women were excluded as disciples and as guests at his heavenly table. Except for
hell he introduced nothing new to ethics or philosophy. He was disrespectful of his mother
and brothers; he said we should hate our parents and desert our families. Mt. 10:35-36, Lk.
14:26 (So much for “Christian family life.”) He denounced anger, but was often angry
himself. Mt. 5:22, Mk. 3:5 He called people “fools” (Mt. 23:17,19), “serpents,” and “white
sepulchers,” though he warned that such language puts you in danger of hellfire. Mt. 5:22
He said “Think not that I am come to send peace on earth. I came not to send peace, but a
sword." Mt. 10:34 (So much for “Peace on Earth.”) He irrationally cursed and withered a fig
tree for being barren out of season. Mt. 21:19 He mandated burning unbelievers. Jn. 15:6
(The Church has complied with relish.) He stole a horse. Lk. 19:30-33 He told people to
cut off hands, feet, eyes and sexual organs. Mt. 5:29-30, 19:12 You want me to accept
Jesus, but I think I'll pick my own friend, thank you.
One of Jesus's many contradictions was saying good works should be seen, and not seen.
Mt. 5:16, 6:1-4 One of his mistakes was saying that the mustard plant has the smallest
seed. Mt. 13:31-32 The writers of Matthew and Luke could not even get his genealogy
straight, contradicting the Old Testament, and giving Jesus two discrepant lines through
Joseph, his non-father!
I also find Christianity to be morally repugnant. The concepts of original sin, depravity,
substitutionary forgiveness, intolerance, eternal punishment, and humble worship are all
beneath the dignity of intelligent human beings and conflict with the values of kindness
and reason. They are barbaric ideas for primitive cultures cowering in fear and
Finally, Christianity is harmful. More people have been killed in the name of a god than
for any other reason. The Church has a shameful, bloody history of Crusades, Inquisitions,
witch-burnings, heresy trials, American colonial intolerance, disrespect of indigenous
traditions (such as American Indians), support of slavery, and oppression of women.
Modern fruits of religion include the Jonestown massacre, the callous fraud
of faith healers, recent wars and ethnic cleansing, and fighting in Northern
Ireland. Religion also poses a danger to mental health, damaging self-respect, personal
responsibility, and clarity of thought.
Do you see why I do not respect the biblical message? It is an insulting bag of nonsense.
You have every right to torment yourself with such insanity but leave me out of
it. I have better things to do with my life.
[ Dan Barker, Losing Fath in Faith: From
Preacher to Atheist. FFRF, Inc. 1992, pp. 214-217. ]
Home Page |
Further Reading |
Site Map |